| 1 | University of Notre Dame | $26,780 | $99,980 | 2.1 yrs |
| 2 | Purdue University-Main Campus | $14,600 | $72,424 | 2.4 yrs |
| 3 | Rose-Hulman Institute of Technology | $42,513 | $101,253 | 3.2 yrs |
| 4 | Marian University-Ancilla | $19,463 | $58,759 | 3.7 yrs |
| 5 | DePauw University | $22,264 | $70,527 | 4 yrs |
| 6 | Indiana University-Bloomington | $16,264 | $63,742 | 4.2 yrs |
| 7 | Wabash College | $24,336 | $69,952 | 4.5 yrs |
| 8 | Butler University | $36,041 | $77,235 | 5 yrs |
| 9 | Valparaiso University | $18,578 | $63,191 | 5 yrs |
| 10 | Indiana Wesleyan University-National & Global | $16,898 | $59,986 | 5.8 yrs |
| 11 | Indiana University-Indianapolis | $11,668 | $55,198 | 6.8 yrs |
| 12 | Trine University-Regional/Non-Traditional Campuses | $15,788 | $57,165 | 7.2 yrs |
| 13 | Indiana Wesleyan University-Marion | $22,866 | $59,986 | 7.9 yrs |
| 14 | Marian University | $24,018 | $58,759 | 9.2 yrs |
| 15 | Saint Mary's College | $25,292 | $59,354 | 9.2 yrs |
| 16 | Indiana University-Kokomo | $3,968 | $49,917 | 10.2 yrs |
| 17 | University of Saint Francis-Fort Wayne | $18,196 | $55,362 | 10.4 yrs |
| 18 | Trine University | $25,355 | $57,165 | 11.5 yrs |
| 19 | Franklin College | $22,855 | $55,376 | 13 yrs |
| 20 | University of Evansville | $18,499 | $53,770 | 13.7 yrs |
| 21 | Hanover College | $21,829 | $53,957 | 15.6 yrs |
| 22 | Goshen College | $14,493 | $51,943 | 16.2 yrs |
| 23 | University of Indianapolis | $21,602 | $53,610 | 16.5 yrs |
| 24 | Ball State University | $14,940 | $51,833 | 17.2 yrs |
| 25 | Manchester University | $18,805 | $51,504 | 23.9 yrs |
| 26 | Taylor University | $24,865 | $52,198 | 25.9 yrs |
| 27 | Earlham College | $24,714 | $50,797 | 40.6 yrs |
| 28 | Holy Cross College | $26,728 | $50,416 | 52 yrs |
| 29 | Bethel University | $18,610 | $48,860 | 148.9 yrs |
| 30 | Anderson University | $25,021 | $48,899 | 185.7 yrs |
| 31 | Indiana State University | $10,873 | $48,387 | 1610.8 yrs |
| 32 | Purdue University Northwest | $6,079 | $48,318 | no payback |
| 33 | Indiana University-Southeast | $7,888 | $47,596 | no payback |
| 34 | Indiana University-East | $8,134 | $47,156 | no payback |
| 35 | University of Southern Indiana | $12,923 | $47,605 | no payback |
| 36 | Purdue University Fort Wayne | $13,171 | $45,872 | no payback |
| 37 | Indiana Institute of Technology-College of Professional Studies | $20,473 | $47,327 | no payback |
| 38 | Indiana University-South Bend | $8,653 | $44,947 | no payback |
| 39 | Huntington University | $19,310 | $46,672 | no payback |
| 40 | Indiana Institute of Technology | $23,206 | $47,327 | no payback |
| 41 | Calumet College of Saint Joseph | $22,451 | $46,945 | no payback |
| 42 | Indiana University-Northwest | $5,130 | $43,361 | no payback |
| 43 | Mid-America College of Funeral Service | $30,606 | $44,505 | no payback |
| 44 | Grace College and Theological Seminary | $19,932 | $45,411 | no payback |
| 45 | Lincoln College of Technology-Indianapolis | $28,371 | $46,396 | no payback |
| 46 | Oakland City University | $15,210 | $43,283 | no payback |
| 47 | Vincennes University | $11,225 | $41,110 | no payback |
| 48 | Saint Mary-of-the-Woods College | $31,872 | $43,845 | no payback |
| 49 | MyComputerCareer at Indianapolis | $26,182 | $41,976 | no payback |
| 50 | Ivy Tech Community College | $7,258 | $37,186 | no payback |
| 51 | Purdue University Global | $7,770 | $36,596 | no payback |
| 52 | Fortis College-Indianapolis | $27,706 | $34,726 | no payback |
| 53 | Aveda Fredric's Institute-Indianapolis | $24,096 | $31,963 | no payback |
| 54 | Tricoci University of Beauty Culture-Indianapolis | $23,951 | $26,446 | no payback |
| 55 | Empire Beauty School-Indianapolis | $17,213 | $24,397 | no payback |
| 56 | Tricoci University of Beauty Culture-Highland | $20,909 | $22,374 | no payback |